Home » articles in progress » Music Industry Models and Crowdfunding, among other things

Music Industry Models and Crowdfunding, among other things

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,249 other followers

RSS Ethnopopgirl on Video Tech and Culture

  • Citizen creative placemaking: my personal backstory November 20, 2017
    When I was an undergraduate college student, I took a class that changed the focus of my life. This is a pretty broad brush to paint on a set of morphing decisions I’d been making for years, but bear with me – I’ve got a point to make. I started out my college career as … Continue reading →
  • Thinking about the role of music October 24, 2017
    So I haven’t posted in a while. Okay, since March (!). But it’s been a busy busy time – I started a new position a year and a half ago and we’ve been developing a new office. It’s taken more time than even I would have anticipated. Great times! I may at some point blog … Continue reading →
  • Chuck Berry -curating sounds and memories March 20, 2017
    Update: (okay, it took less than a couple of hours to get to this, but you knew I would). I have to include this wonderful retrospective by Peter Guralnick about his interview with Berry, Little Richard, Jerry Lee Lewis, and Fats Domino in New Orleans in 2011. (You think of trying to interview them as … Continue reading →
  • Total randomness – how else to deal with this year’s Oscars? February 28, 2017
    I’m a fairly rabid reader of The New Yorker, for what it’s worth. And today’s article on the glitch in the Best Picture Awards at the Oscars this year struck me as one of those moments where we create our own soundtrack. Since I’ve been posting on this blog more regularly lately, I thought I’d share … Continue reading →
  • RIP Clyde Stubblefield February 21, 2017
    There are far too many losses to the music world, this year, and every year – maybe last year just sensitized me to it or maybe we’re getting to that generational shift? Either way, today I’m sharing the soundtrack that’s guiding my morning and a brief obit from Digital Music News. Let the Funky Drummer … Continue reading →
  • Remembering Al Jarreau February 13, 2017
    Just a quick post today. Al Jarreau was one of the voices of my childhood and teen years – one of the happy, beautiful voices that countermanded all the emotional art rock I consumed at the same time. This tribute was put together by Wisconsin Public Radio – there’s a request by his family to … Continue reading →
  • Thinking about protest music, the Women’s March, and Joan Baez February 7, 2017
    Rolling Stone published an interview with Joan Baez yesterday about the Women’s March and protest music. While I strongly recommend reading it, there are a couple of highlights I’m thinking about. There’s a lack of music as a positive, uplifting (Baez’s word) force right now – protests are focused on anger. This movement needs an … Continue reading → […]
  • On protest music in the current age 1.28.17 January 28, 2017
    I’ve renewed an old research interest – protest music. Not terribly a shocking interest for an ethnomusicologist in the crazy times we’re seeing, but it’s been a recurring theme in my toolkit of research subjects. John Mellencamp (whose work I don’t normally look at) just released a really interesting song that takes on inequality, protest … Continue reading […]
  • Mourning 2016 Musicians – Glenn Frey January 18, 2017
    This is just a brief post but I anticipate more of these to follow – every one of the artists I miss deserves a post of his/her own. So I’m still not over last year’s losses. And by that I mean the musicians lost to the world when they died last year. For me this … Continue reading →
  • A guest blog from my new housemates August 5, 2016
    I broke down this week and did something I avoid – I went to the local animal shelter (because I can’t go without bringing home new friends). Even worse, I went into the kitten room and was immediately accosted by two small feline persons who informed me in no uncertain terms that I was taking … Continue reading →

Ethnopopgirl Archived

Blog Stats

  • 871 hits

NetworkedBlogs on Facebook


My research has turned, over the past two years, specifically towards the impact of technology on working musicians in the music industry. Probably because I’m like most American performers, my focus has been split: on the one hand I’m very tuned towards the pop musics I listen to, but on the other hand there is the art music tradition I was trained in. Both share the historic tradition of institutionalized patronage, either through the elite classes that employed performers up until Beethoven (though there is a real case to be made that in northern Europe that tradition continued for a good generation past his death) and since in a more limited capacity through institutionalized arts organizations. In the (capitalist) pop music world this got transformed into the corporate label structure that still economically dominates our cultural production.

Writing this post today comes out of two projects I’m working on: an article on the impact and place of remixes, and an article (and one of a series of conference papers) on the impact social media are having on the everyday of artist production. I like to style myself as an early adopter, though by the standards of some of my friends might be questionable – probably more correctly I should say I’m just a semiotician fascinated with mediation and any object or interaction that mediates communication between a performer and another interlocutor.

In that spirit, a fellow G+ follower posted this piece yesterday on his blog, correctly labeling (as I see it), the connection between these two economic models of music production. I started to write a comment at the end of his post but decided to respond in kind.

I think a lot of folks are trying out all sorts of alternate paths (with mixed results) – I’m curious how you’d react to an idea I’ve been playing with that the business model we’re moving towards is more entrepreneurial, rather than corporate in its focus. DIY takes over business. The problem, of course, is the old patronage systems has entrenched institutional support. Where things get interesting from my perspective as an ethnomusicologist and a popular music scholar is the different interactions that political and other public institutions (are there any public institutions that aren’t political?) are having.

I’ve been researching Kickstarter and other crowdfunding (or fanfunding if you will) venues for a while now and I’m noticing that there are very different ways that communities (within the same nation and across national/cultural boundaries) as well as genres are responding to the model of funding represented. Part of the issue I see is that it really pulls from an assumption of an American/continental U.S. customer service model – which, as any traveler knows, is not uniformly accepted. Even in the U.S., as one friend of mine put it to me last month, the question needs to be asked: “which America” is being represented in crowdfunding at all?

In the past six months I’ve started talking with a great guy who runs a crowdfunding site that takes Kickstarter/Artistshare  and their ilk as a starting place and, literally, revisits the idea of patronage. Calling it Patron21, the site was launched based on the very reasonable premise that funding a project is great, but it won’t pay your light bill once that project is done. And it also won’t help you pay your taxes (FYI, y’all who are running Kickstarter campaigns know that the money you raise – at least in the U.S. – is considered taxable income?) at the end of the year.

Over the past four months I’ve given two conference papers particularly focused on Kickstarter and Wepay campaigns run by musicians who are interlocutors of mine. Most recently in April I presented at the British Forum for Ethnomusicology/ICTM-Ireland annual meeting and had the great fortune to hear a paper about fanfunding by British ethnomusicologist Mark Thorley (Note: Fanfunding and crowdfunding are often used interchangeably. I tend to stick to crowdfunding because of the embedded meanings in the term fanfunding, but that’s my own scholarly two-cents’ worth.) While I’m still hoping for an opportunity to have this conversation with him live, (and it was a great paper, IMO) what struck me was that the jazz community he has been working with resented the customer service-oriented assumptions of “perks.” I’ve spent the intervening time revisiting the assumptions I’m hearing and reading – or rather, not hearing and reading, in blogs, articles, and discourse around social media and crowdfunding. What I’m seeing is how amazingly entrenched the old patronage model is, and, even more, the extent to which American cultural imperialism of a particular sort gets exported and transported along with culture production models.

That’s it for now. More goes to my next conference paper on the technologies here, which I’m presenting in July at the Art of Record Production conference in Quebec City. You can guess I have a lot to say about this.


Postscript: I just started reading an interview with actress Robin Wright in Salon.com about her new film, and how crazy that she’s talking about that same issue of corporate ownership in media/culture industries? Go figure. But it cracks me up that they sell the article with the age/gender issues of being an actress over the age of 40 in Hollywood movie culture.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: