Home » articles in progress » A Manifesto of Sorts – Draft 2

A Manifesto of Sorts – Draft 2

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,249 other followers

RSS Ethnopopgirl on Video Tech and Culture

  • Citizen creative placemaking: my personal backstory November 20, 2017
    When I was an undergraduate college student, I took a class that changed the focus of my life. This is a pretty broad brush to paint on a set of morphing decisions I’d been making for years, but bear with me – I’ve got a point to make. I started out my college career as … Continue reading →
  • Thinking about the role of music October 24, 2017
    So I haven’t posted in a while. Okay, since March (!). But it’s been a busy busy time – I started a new position a year and a half ago and we’ve been developing a new office. It’s taken more time than even I would have anticipated. Great times! I may at some point blog … Continue reading →
  • Chuck Berry -curating sounds and memories March 20, 2017
    Update: (okay, it took less than a couple of hours to get to this, but you knew I would). I have to include this wonderful retrospective by Peter Guralnick about his interview with Berry, Little Richard, Jerry Lee Lewis, and Fats Domino in New Orleans in 2011. (You think of trying to interview them as … Continue reading →
  • Total randomness – how else to deal with this year’s Oscars? February 28, 2017
    I’m a fairly rabid reader of The New Yorker, for what it’s worth. And today’s article on the glitch in the Best Picture Awards at the Oscars this year struck me as one of those moments where we create our own soundtrack. Since I’ve been posting on this blog more regularly lately, I thought I’d share … Continue reading →
  • RIP Clyde Stubblefield February 21, 2017
    There are far too many losses to the music world, this year, and every year – maybe last year just sensitized me to it or maybe we’re getting to that generational shift? Either way, today I’m sharing the soundtrack that’s guiding my morning and a brief obit from Digital Music News. Let the Funky Drummer … Continue reading →
  • Remembering Al Jarreau February 13, 2017
    Just a quick post today. Al Jarreau was one of the voices of my childhood and teen years – one of the happy, beautiful voices that countermanded all the emotional art rock I consumed at the same time. This tribute was put together by Wisconsin Public Radio – there’s a request by his family to … Continue reading →
  • Thinking about protest music, the Women’s March, and Joan Baez February 7, 2017
    Rolling Stone published an interview with Joan Baez yesterday about the Women’s March and protest music. While I strongly recommend reading it, there are a couple of highlights I’m thinking about. There’s a lack of music as a positive, uplifting (Baez’s word) force right now – protests are focused on anger. This movement needs an … Continue reading → […]
  • On protest music in the current age 1.28.17 January 28, 2017
    I’ve renewed an old research interest – protest music. Not terribly a shocking interest for an ethnomusicologist in the crazy times we’re seeing, but it’s been a recurring theme in my toolkit of research subjects. John Mellencamp (whose work I don’t normally look at) just released a really interesting song that takes on inequality, protest … Continue reading […]
  • Mourning 2016 Musicians – Glenn Frey January 18, 2017
    This is just a brief post but I anticipate more of these to follow – every one of the artists I miss deserves a post of his/her own. So I’m still not over last year’s losses. And by that I mean the musicians lost to the world when they died last year. For me this … Continue reading →
  • A guest blog from my new housemates August 5, 2016
    I broke down this week and did something I avoid – I went to the local animal shelter (because I can’t go without bringing home new friends). Even worse, I went into the kitten room and was immediately accosted by two small feline persons who informed me in no uncertain terms that I was taking … Continue reading →

Ethnopopgirl Archived

Blog Stats

  • 871 hits

NetworkedBlogs on Facebook


I read back through Draft 1 and realized that I did it again – I started in the middle and took it for granted that you all (the figurative you all – you who are not me who are reading this) know what I know – the eureka moment that got me started on studying rehearsals and performances.

It’s true that this isn’t the real beginning. That, unfortunately, would mean telling you my life story and doing the thing that irritates every experienced scholar; hearing someone say, “since the beginning of recorded history” – always a red flag. This is, though, the beginning of when I began to think about the construction of performance actively.

The date is June, 1993. It’s probably a Sunday, and I’m definitely at a string quartet recital at a church in Old Town on the near north side of Chicago. Ernest Hemingway’s old neighborhood, incidentally. He lived across the street and down the block when he first got married. I know this because around the same time as the story I’m telling, I taught about two months’ worth of piano lessons to a woman who lived in the apartment below what had been Hemingway’s. A neat bit of history. At least I was impressed by it.

Saint Chrysostom’s – they do still have a regular music series.

The church was a lovely old thing, and the recital was one of those moderately nice shebangs with a wine and cheese for starters. I don’t for the life of me remember who the quartet was or why we went, but if what I just looked up is right, the concert was free, which probably explains it. Confession of a researcher – just went back and looked this up and found the picture, too (see left). The address would indeed be 1239 North Dearborn, the woman seems to have had it right, and the church I’m speaking of is on the southwest corner of Dearborn and Division Streets. I’ll probably figure out which one because it’s going to bother me if I don’t. The church, though, seems to be two blocks up on the 1400 block.

I remember the space was lovely, and I sat in the recital space with a cocktail napkin in my hand. One of those – moments – hit me. I don’t know how to describe it any more precisely than that, but I think it’s because the ensemble – the ways the members of the quartet played and even breathed together – of the group was just superb. I got chills down my back. I can count the number of times in my life that has happened, and each of them has bound me tighter to the world of music.

Now we have the scene. I’m sitting next to my (now ex)husband, cocktail napkin in hand, and with chills running down my back because whatever they were played just knocked my socks off. And it wasn’t the piece – notice I couldn’t for the world tell what that was now – it was the way they played. All I could think was, how can they have done this? They are four different people, with four different brains, trained by four different sets of musicians (every musician that reaches professional status has had many teachers, and will frequently count music coaches and conductors as well as other ensemble members among their musical influences). They have different musical pulses and vocabularies. And yet – they are creating one thing. One performance. One understandable, coherent story, without a conductor. This, I knew, happened in the rehearsal space – when professional groups have time to rehearse, as my friend Kareem just reminded me the other day.

I wanted to understand how this happens. I did not know why it was important, I just knew it was and that it is.

Now, almost twenty years later, I have something of a theory. Of course. My theory is that we listen in different ways to the people around us. We listen to their experiences and to their stories. When we like someone, or we feel comfortable with someone, not only do we listen better, but we allow our playing to shape to the sounds we hear coming from that other person. Kareem was telling me that apparently brain wave research shows that even brain waves become more similar in this kind of situation.

Your, very reasonable, question is going to be, so what? You’ve been listening to me, I see. I ask people that all the time, particularly if they are my students. What’s important about this kind of listening? This kind of listening shows a relationship between the values a person has that come from his or her culture and the ways that this person will be willing to communicate with someone from a different culture. We see this with performers all the time. Not all performers are so flexible or understanding, but many are. We see less racism – if a performer can do the job and do it well, what matter his/her religion, or color of his/her skin? (at least while the person is playing)

I’m a Terry Pratchett fan, so of course my go-to book this past year has been his recent book Snuff. Okay, if you’re a Pratchett fan and you want to complain that his dialogue is not what it used to be, I won’t argue with you. Pratchett, though, has this way of talking about what I like to talk about as the “elephants in the room.” Snuff takes on racism – when a group looks too different, acts too differently, thinks too differently – people will treat them as less than human, less than equal. In Snuff it’s goblins that are the discriminated against group – until Lady Sybil (my hero, Commander Vimes – girly sigh-‘s wife) hears a goblin girl playing harp. This girl plays so beautifully that Sybil, who’s a sharp lady and much more honest with herself than most people, recognizes her own biases, and helps change the way society sees goblins. She arranges for the goblin girl, named Tears of a Mushroom, to have a solo harp performance in the Ankh-Morpork – Pratchett’s version of New York City, London, and maybe Paris all rolled up in one – opera house.

In real life these things don’t happen. One concert isn’t enough – but we try this all the time anyhow. What about Daniel Barenboim’s Israeli-Palestinian orchestra work? And any other international effort you care to name that tries to establish cross-cultural ties through music making? At my high school, “Dedicated to the Promotion of World Friendship through the Universal Language of the Arts” is posted on the back of the stage where all the major summer performances take place.

Kresge Auditorium stage at the Interlochen Center for the Arts.

It’s pretentious, I’ll grant you, but this idea of connections that we can make through performance is an ideal many performers work towards.

This doesn’t mean that human behavior doesn’t get in the way. I became an ethnomusicologist somewhere along the way. A few years ago, at the annual conference for the Society of Ethnomusicology, I saw a paper presented about musicians who met and recorded rap online in Europe. They were, variously, from Germany and Iran. Musically they got along great. The Iranian rappers somehow got permission to travel to Germany for a music festival but once they got there all that communication went downhill. Politics got in the way, partly because those Iranian musicians knew they were going to get arrested as soon as they got back home.

The point I’m trying to make is that I tapped into something that lots of us in the arts are aware of, but we mostly don’t talk about. Ethnomusicologists do which, I think, is why I became one. Why is it performers do what they do? This is what I want to know. I’ll leave it to the psychologists and neuroscientists to figure out how.

Part 3 will connect up the dots between Parts 1 and 2. As always, comments are welcome.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: